Choking it down: For some, ruling confirms belief that assurances of former EPA head after 9/11 are hard to swallowNewsdayFeb. 04, 2006 |
Mark Levin Accuses Me of 'Trying to Commit Violence' Against Him by Clipping His Show
Ben Shapiro Pushes Noahide Laws at TPUSA Event, Throws a Fit Over Being Quoted Word-For-Word
From Aid to Dependency: Israeli Agent Reveals the Real Goal of 'Merging' U.S. and Israeli Militaries
ADL, Jewish Groups Lobby California to Classify Jews as a Race, 'Not Just a Faith'
House Passes NDAA With Section 219 Aimed at 'Merging' U.S. and Israeli Militaries
![]() Mike Keane, owner of O'Hara's Pub & Restaurant on Cedar Street in lower Manhattan, said he and everybody else who fled the Ground Zero area knew what former Environmental Protection Agency chief Christine Todd Whitman said she didn't know. The billowing cloud of debris from the pulverized World Trade Center site was dangerous, he said Friday while tending bar for a late lunch crowd. "Everybody knew it wasn't good," said Keane about the dirt-laden atmosphere in lower Manhattan after Sept. 11. Everybody, that is, except Whitman, whose assurances to the public that the air had no significant levels of asbestos might very well have been divorced from reality, according to a recent ruling by a federal judge. "She was lying through her teeth," Keane, 43, said of Whitman. On Thursday, Manhattan federal Judge Deborah Batts ruled that Whitman could be sued for telling New Yorkers that the air was safe enough to allow people to return within a week to downtown Manhattan after the terror attacks. Batts said that Whitman didn't have immunity as a public official for making those remarks, statements that the EPA's own Office of Inspector General found inaccurate in 2003. Batts didn't rule on the merits of the lawsuit, which seeks damages from Whitman and the EPA, as well as the creation of a fund to finance medical monitoring services. But Batts' decision sparked outrage from people living and working around Ground Zero. New York politicians, including Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, also weighed in Friday, saying Whitman and the EPA were at best uninformed or at worst lying. "New Yorkers deserve to ... know what health threats they were exposed to and which ones still could pose dangers to them," Clinton said at a news conference. She was joined by Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D-Manhattan) and residents from the Ground Zero area. Clinton said she plans to put together an independent body of experts to study the extent of the contamination around Ground Zero. A representative for the EPA in New York City referred calls to the federal Department of Justice, where spokesman Charles Miller said the agency was reviewing Batts' ruling. Whitman, who resigned in 2003 and now runs a consulting firm, said in a statement Friday that she was "outraged" by the judge's decision. "I firmly believe that the agency's findings that the air quality was safe were correct," Whitman said. New Yorkers suing Whitman and the EPA alleged that she and the agency made false statements about the air quality after the attacks and had failed to ensure a cleanup of carcinogens and other hazardous substances from Ground Zero. In the wake of Batts' decision, those around Ground Zero reacted with anger and concern. Richard Hu, owner of Wall Street Humidor, a cigar store on Warren Street, said, "For a government official to blatantly lie to us is totally irresponsible." Hu, 56, said his business was closed for a month after Sept. 11 and that dust was 2 inches thick on the floor. Keane, who said the air was filled with particulates in the days after the attacks, reopened six months later. He pulled out a scrapbook of pictures that showed the pub facade covered in a ghostly white powder. Staff writer Herb Lowe contributed to this story. What she said A sampling of then-EPA chief Christine Todd Whitman's statements on air quality in Lower Manhattan following the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks: Sept. 14, 2001: "If you're at the center of the site, if you're at Ground Zero, obviously there are a lot of irritants. They need to be wearing masks. They need to be wearing scarves. Actually they should be wearing the masks that we've been providing for them, but for the population as a whole, if you're not in the immediate area, all the samplings that we have been doing have been showing nothing that should cause a health concern. "Obviously, if you have health problems, you have breathing problems, you don't come out and do your deep breathing exercises outside, but you should be all right." Sept. 18, 2001: "I am glad to reassure the people of New York ... that their air is safe to breathe and their water is safe to drink." Oct. 3, 2001: "Our data show that contaminant levels are low or nonexistent and are generally confined to the Trade Center site." |