State attorney: Jacksonville police shooting at Wendy's justifiedThe number of shots fired was not a factor.Florida Times-Union Jun. 03, 2010 |
Mark Levin Accuses Me of 'Trying to Commit Violence' Against Him by Clipping His Show
Ben Shapiro Pushes Noahide Laws at TPUSA Event, Throws a Fit Over Being Quoted Word-For-Word
From Aid to Dependency: Israeli Agent Reveals the Real Goal of 'Merging' U.S. and Israeli Militaries
ADL, Jewish Groups Lobby California to Classify Jews as a Race, 'Not Just a Faith'
Israel Lobby Seeking to Revamp U.S. Aid as 'Partnership' Immune to Political Shifts
![]() Prosecutors said Tuesday they found no criminal wrongdoing by five Jacksonville police officers who fired 42 shots at a robbery/carjacking suspect in March, killing the man and leaving a boy and his mother injured. "Our determination here is not whether or not we think the police acted correctly in strategy, where they set up or the number of shots fired," said State Attorney Angela Corey. "Our analysis is whether they were justified in even pulling the trigger that first time. We concluded they were." During an afternoon news conference, Corey gave five reasons the killing of Jeremiah Mathis on March 26 outside a Baymeadows Road Wendy's was justified under state law: - Mathis was armed, had just robbed a bank and was attempting to carjack a vehicle to escape. - The first responding officer ordered Mathis to stop and warned he would be shot if he didn't. - That officer knew Mathis was armed and heard him threaten to kill Joann Cooper, the driver of the vehicle he sought to carjack. - The first shots were fired knowing Mathis was violent, armed, refused to obey police and threatened to kill Cooper and/or police. - The other officers acted to prevent Mathis from harming Cooper, police or other bystanders. Talk of the Town: Do you think the police shooting was justified? Prosecutor Bernie de la Rionda said during the news conference that witness Cordero Anderson, who told The Times-Union that he saw Mathis raise his hands outside the car's driver's door at one point as if to surrender, said under oath that he neither saw hands raised nor heard an offer to surrender. Neither did anyone else, de la Rionda said. "He never put his hands up and never said [I] give up," de la Rionda said of Mathis. However, a partial viewing de la Rionda gave the Times-Union of Anderson's videotaped statement shows Anderson at various points demonstrating how he saw bare hands being raised from the car. Cordero admits he's not sure whose hands he saw or why they were raised. He also said he was mistaken at one point when he initially said he saw the hands come from the passenger door. Police said Mathis robbed a nearby Wachovia Bank and then carjacked Cooper and two of her children. She and her 2-year-old son, Daniel Crichton, were injured in the subsequent gunfire. Her daughter was not injured. An attorney for the survivor's family declined to comment. Cachandra Mathis, Mathis' sister, said her family found Tuesday's decision "disgusting." "They could have shot him once and let him have his day in court," said Mathis, 37, of New York. Two of the officers remain on desk duty as a Sheriff's Office review board will determine if they or the others involved violated departmental policies. Sheriff John Rutherford has kept Officer Ryan Black and recruit Darries Griffith off the street because of his concerns they fired 30 of the 42 shots into Cooper's moving vehicle. While their actions were deemed legal, whether Black and Griffith acted appropriately is linked to a police policy that prohibits officers from firing at a moving vehicle other than as a last resort to prevent death or great bodily harm to the officer or another person. Among the things officers must consider when they use deadly force is what is around and behind the target -- also known as the backstop -- and whether the shooting could harm someone else. [email protected], (904) 359-4385 Subscription Offer Subscribe to The Florida Times-Union Related Stories
Comments (117) I know someone who was at the By LadyBlahBlah | 06/01/10 - 02:06 I know someone who was at the scene as a first responder and vehemently disagrees with this finding. The scene=the car and shot baby.
Thank you Jesus, that Shorestein is gone By Typical WM | 06/01/10 - 02:12 I could not stand that anti-cop liberal snake. Way to Go Angela!!! Anyone who points a gun at me is going to feel my wrath too. Stupid People Should not Have The Right To Breed!
This will be in the civil courts without a doubt By just kidding right | 06/01/10 - 02:33 Then we'll see.
Line 'em up and knock 'em down By knotguilty | 06/01/10 - 02:56 Way to go JSO and Angela Corey! In all this talk of budget cuts there has not been mention of reducing the amount of bullets issued, thank God. However, if it comes down to it, I'll buy your ammo. You just keep putting that hot lead to GOOD USE! If police involved shootings bother you - get your CWP and beat them to it! Thank you JSO. I saw your billboard and you are truly "under fire daily".
Seriously, the cops can do no wrong? By ace5on4 | 06/01/10 - 03:06 Angela Corey is just a tool for Nelson Cuba, period. John Rutherford is a good man, but just like mayor Peyton, he doesn't have what it takes (the vision, or the fortitude) to take a stand to the forces that be and make the changes needed in our police units. With all of the police shootings we have had since Corey has been the state attorney the police havn't been wrong once, really? I thought Jesus was the only person who was without sin. The cops can't been right everytime? I'm not commenting on this particular case because I really wasn't there and this article leaves out a lot of details important details needed to form a logic unbiased opinion. But seriously it seems really unlikely that with the large number of police involved shootings that we have had in this city going back to the 70s and all of the FBI investigations that our city police have gone through over the years it seems really unlikely that the police are never wrong.
Out of control JSO By ignored tax payer | 06/01/10 - 03:14 Since when is it ok to fire 42 shots into a moving vehicle with hostiges inside in the center of an urbanized area? The JSO is absolutely out of control. I feel for the poor woman who thought she was going to be shot by a car-jacker and ended up getting shot (and her son) by a trigger happy police officer. How's that for service?!? Get control of yourselves "public servants"!
I this surprising? By George J | 06/01/10 - 03:16 Gross incompetence by the police is rarely against the law. It will still cost the city millions. Have fun paying for that Duval residents.
Sorry By CasualObserver | 06/01/10 - 03:26 Sorry that Jeremiah Mathis put this innocent family in harms way, and that they were injured. It is a shame we can't send his family a bill for the damage he caused. As for Jeremiah Mathis himself - glad to have JSO take out the trash. We give out JSO officer magazines filled with bullets for a reason - we don't want these violent thugs showing up in an emergency room. A cold slab in the morgue is the only cure to our revidicism rate.
Typical WM... By ignored tax payer | 06/01/10 - 03:23 So what type of gun did the woman who was car-jacked point at those police officers? How about the toddler in the back seat? Or are they just collateral damage? Perhaps your life is worth more than there's because you wear a badge and are "under fire all the time". What exactly does "serve and protect" mean? Serve your own agenda? Protect your own life over all others? How about using a little discretion when drawing your firearm. Like checking to see if there is a toddler sitting behind your target!
CasualObserver... By ignored tax payer | 06/01/10 - 03:27 "We give out JSO officer magazines filled with bullets for a reason - we don't want these violent thugs showing up in an emergency room." Seriously? I guess its ok to put innocent victims in the emergency room? They were lucky to not end up in the morgue! Its not a video game out there - so use some common sense.
JSO incompetence By stevemary | 06/01/10 - 03:26 A gang with guns,nothing more ! They are just criminals wearing a badge that they think grants them the right to shoot anything that moves. Least of all they need to learn how to aim those glocks correctly. JSO----JACKLEGS SCREWING OFF
@Ignored By CasualObserver | 06/01/10 - 03:31 Like I said, I am sorry that Mathis caused the family to be injured. As for Mathis, if he was found with 500 bullet holes, you wouldn't hear me complaining about JSO overdoing it. Those bullets only cost about a quarter each. The lives affected by thugs like Matthis are invaluable.
BS By McQ | 06/01/10 - 03:35 typical WM - I'm sorry but you are not typical - assuming WM stands for white male. Since when is it OK for cops to shoot 42 times, miss the car the majority of them for g'ds sake and still manage to hit 2 hostages? I have no problem with the criminal being shot - but I have a lot of problems with the way it went down, the hostages being shot and the lack of control or aim of the cops. I do not expect police I am paying to support to just start blasting away with no self control or ability to hit what they are aiming at.
I agree By D.C | 06/01/10 - 03:36 It is justified to kill a POS that carjacked this lady's car. But is it justified to shoot into a car with hostages 42 times? That's the issue here. Sure I can believe the officers heard Mathis threaten to kill the hostage, but did they have to try to do it instead? Anybody with any law enforcement sense, should know that a threat was made to keep the cops from shooting him. Why would he shoot his human shield? They're fortunate this lady and baby lived, but I bet the civil suit will justify them. Put me in charge. I'll make your life better. I'm on a one man crusade against drivers who refuse to use signals.
So the potential hijacked victim is sueing the city? By word of mouse | 06/01/10 - 03:37 What for? Saving Her Life.
Oh no JSO....!!! By greginjax | 06/01/10 - 03:39 I have to say I am agreeing with this finding. JSO is going to discipline the officers and if anything they should be counciled on using better judgement. That said, I have stated on the issue before unless you have ever been in a situation like this or know how this stuff goes down you should reserve judgement. It all happens in a flash and there is little time to react or make a decision. They were worried he would drive off in the car, potentially running into others and killing them. Is 42 shots excessive, yeah kinda, but only 17 hit the car and no one except the bad guy is dead. If you like JSO can take it's time saving you. American Ambition and Spirit is no match for liberal stupidity and foolishness.
casualobserver... By ignored tax payer | 06/01/10 - 03:50 "Like I said, I am sorry that Mathis caused the family to be injured." That's BS and you know it. Mathis didn't shoot that woman and her son - JSO did. Why did they do it? Because they are poorly trained police officers who think they're living in the wild freaking west. Go back and read all of the news articles regarding out of control police officers putting citizens in harms way with the weapons they've been issued, the police cars they've been issued and the badges they've been issued. This isn't about one bad guy who got what was coming to him. This is about police officers not having any common sense.
greginjax... By ignored tax payer | 06/01/10 - 03:58 You're right, these things do happen in a flash. That is why police officers are supposed to be well trained; so when put in this position they can respond appropriately. These two officers obviously were not trained properly because they emptied their mags on a moving vehicle full of hostiges. "Is 42 shots excessive, yeah kinda, but only 17 hit the car" Is that supposed to give us some kind of comfort? I feel a lot better knowing that JSO can only hit a car from close range 40% of the time. Its a good thing other innocent bystanders weren't hit by the 25 bullets that missed the entire car.
Jesus would've shot to kill By vango | 06/01/10 - 04:05 So Jesus was a violent gun nut, just like all the modern-day Christian right-wing nitwits.
Solution By knotguilty | 06/01/10 - 04:13 I see through this thread that an obvious solution may be issuing each officer a sniper rifle or at least "long" guns with optics. Perhaps firing for effect is not the best tactic and one well placed round would lessen the fiscal burden on the tax payer. Now the only question that remains is, which caliber? I would like to suggest a 50BMG, but from time-to-time I am an over achiever. Please go get your concealed weapons permit and carry daily. Victim or victor - you decide.
Greg - JSO Judgement being Questioned By Tabmoc | 06/01/10 - 04:32 "They were worried he would drive off in the car, potentially running into others and killing them. Is 42 shots excessive, yeah kinda, but only 17 hit the car and no one except the bad guy is dead." A - worried he would drive off - why not shoot out the tires? Why not ram the vehicle? 42 shots not kinda excessive - it's extremely excessive. It's not much different than a drive by shooting - and about as accurate. B - 17 hit the car - yippie. Where did the other 25 rounds go? Into an office building. Maybe the pizza place next door. Or the Chinese restaurant? Would it be OK if it was your wife or girlfriend leaving the nearby gym and she got clipped in the leg, or stomach? Would it be OK if my little girl took one in the leg - one that was intended for the robber but didn't even hit the car? As for the lawsuit against the city - I understand there's a $5,000 cap on those, so maybe they can get $5,000 for each person so maybe $10K? That probably won't cover the hospital bills - and the insurance company probably has denied the claims as pre-existing conditions - the child was already shot when they arrived at the hospital. I would say nearly everyone wants to support the police, and I would disagree bashing them all as out-of-control cowboys - but we increasingly are seeing a police department where officers are demonstrating poor judgement with lethal results.
If By CasualObserver | 06/01/10 - 04:41 Had Matthis been allowed to drive away, he could have crashed and killed the occupants going up I95. If Matthis had driven away and escaped, he could have used his gun to kill the occupants to remove witnesses. I am sorry the innocent passengers were wounded, but was that a worse outcome then probably would have occured had the police just let Matthis take off? Would I rather police had shot him in the head a second before he slid into the drivers seat? You bet.
Common Sense By Tedberens | 06/01/10 - 04:46 42 shots fired in a hostage situation is inexcusable. I realize there was no time for a sniper team, but every bullet has to be carefully placed in a situation like this and that's simply not the case when there are 42 discharges.
I think...... By mikey | 06/01/10 - 05:06 I think the maximum the family can get from the city is $250,000. They may not get a lawyer to take the case for that.
Criminal charges By fozzy | 06/01/10 - 05:09 You people that disagree with this finding need to realize that the state attorney was not there to determine if JSO violated procedure when they shot at the car. They were there to determine if there was a reason to shoot in the first place. There definitely was a reason to shoot. The man committed multiple violent felonies and was armed with a gun. That means the police can shoot him. Their finding does not mean that the police officers are free of any administrative findings or free from being fired. I would guess that one gets fired and one gets suspended. We'll just have to wait and see.
Mikey By Tabmoc | 06/01/10 - 05:09 I thought I read it was $5K after the lady that got hit in the Shands parking lot fiasco. If it's $250K - they'll go for it.
If... By ignored tax payer | 06/01/10 - 05:14 If those officers had it to do all over again would they fire off 42 rounds into a moving vehicle full of innocent victims they are sworn to "protect and serve"? NO! You can play the what if game all day long to defend gross incompetance and a severe lack of training. The facts are: - 42 shots fired into a moving vehicle - only 40% of those rounds actually hit the vehicle - 3 innocent victims in said moving vehicle - 2 innocent victims shot by JSO - 1 innocent victim spent significant time in the ICU and survival was in question - 2 officers on desk duty because their poor judgement was a liability to the citizens of Jacksonville There are plenty of good officers working the streets today. We should not defend those few officers who put innocent lives in danger or think they are above the law.
WOW By Autumn Blue | 06/01/10 - 05:55 Did anyone in Jacksonville expect Angela Corey to go against the police department on this one?
facts By the real truth and facts | 06/01/10 - 06:20 It takes law enforcement to stand up to protect the innocent lives of citizens. To all of you thinking that 17 of 42 shots is bad, think again. This was a moving vehicle or a moving target. Those of you who think you could do better also think again, this is NOT a xbox 360 game, where you can replay parts until you get them right. This was a act now incident. The criminal in question was a repeat offender who committed a bank robbery. Force should have been used.
It takes a world class dummy to say the following... By Wilbur | 06/01/10 - 06:32 "It's disgusting," said Cachandra Mathis, 37, who lives in New York. "They could have shot him once and let him have his day in court." Lee Mathis, 39, also said he felt his brother's death was not justified. "I can't see how it was justified if none of their lives were even put in jeopardy," Mathis said. "Apparently it took time for everybody to get their lies together." Brilliant!really, I am speechless.
FYI to someone By greginjax | 06/01/10 - 06:37 Whoever said the idea of shooting the tires? That is against procedure. The training is very specific you aim for your target, in the chest, NOT tires. You have been watching too many movies, that does not work in real life. American Ambition and Spirit is no match for liberal stupidity and foolishness.
sorry... By AraK | 06/01/10 - 06:57 I'm sorry, but ANYONE who takes up for the bank robber "Mathis" is a pathetic loser who is most likely a felon themselves or has kids that are...YES I agree that JSO shouldn't have shot at the car 42 times, but they did...and 2 officers are on and should continue on until they receive counseling and training. He had a gun, and was KIDNAPPING those innocent people with a LOADED GUN AFTER ROBBING A BANK! I MEAN C'MON people...wake up!
I said Shoot Tires By Tabmoc | 06/01/10 - 07:24 If it's against procedure - then I stand corrected - is stopping a vehicle by ramming against procedures? If not, on a crowded mid-day Baymeadows Road would have been better. People are right - we cannot fairly judge everything because we have 20/20 hindsight - but we can judge this - Two innocent civilians were wounded in a hail of gunfire. It was not a desired outcome - and procedures should have been in place to end the situation without the injury to civilians. Period. And I would not be suprised if such procedures do in fact exist, and the officers didn't follow them.
the real truth and facts is simply ill informed. By George J | 06/01/10 - 08:47 The car was barely moving. It certainly wasn't running down the free way. 42 shots was gross incompetence. My family is not backdrop for incompetent or poorly trained officers. Casualobserver is also an idiot. Maybe his family is OK to be shot at by out of control police but mine certainly is not.
Arak By George J | 06/01/10 - 08:49 Your emotion fueled liberal response is telling. If you people continue to make excuses for sub-standard police work then all you will get is sub-standard police work.
facts george j By the real truth and facts | 06/01/10 - 09:14 Let me guess you were glad because you were holding up the bank down the street. See this is how it works, criminals break the law, when they put other lives in jeopardy they get shot. If a criminal will not stop with words it then turns to force with guns. Criminals do not listen to police that is why they get shot. If criminals would listen, instead they would be in jail. But criminals do not like jail, so they run and sometimes shoot at police. You complain about the number of shots, how about one shot from a bazooka instead. That would have killed all of them. The police killed the criminal when he was trying to escape with 2 people kidnapped. The 2 innocent people came out alive and are able to continue with their lives. That is more than the criminal would give them. So granted in a dream world, we wish all of the bullets would only hit the criminal and no one else would be the perfect solution. what george does not realize is this is just like a war. The police side on the law and with people who do not break the law. The criminals break the law by any means necessary and do whatever it takes to get away. Criminals do not play fair. Criminals take hostages. Gross incompetence is exactly what you will get with our mayor hiring anyone off the street and putting a gun in their hands. If your family george was in that car, you would be shooting at the car yourself with zero training trying to get them back. It is also very easy to keep your family out of those situations, be responsible, act responsible and when you see something going on get away do not sit and watch. Just like you george sitting by and watching, you get into trouble. If you were there george, instead of watching, maybe you should have offered to give the criminal a ride so you could get a good picture. george, you also could have helped if you were there and know so much but I bet you messed your diaper and were not of any good to anyone.
the real truth and facts By George J | 06/01/10 - 09:45 Paragraph after paragraph of meaningless blather. I have more firearms practice than probably 75% of JSO and unarmed fighting experience than about 90% I would guess. If a criminal gets in my car all JSO will have to do is come clean up the body. And no this is not like a war. We have a Constitution and laws that outline how government is to act. Shooting wildly into an occupied vehicle is incompetence. You may settle for that but I demand better from the people charged to protect and serve. It they cannot meet that standard then find others who can. I have been shot at. I have been cut and stabbed. I do not scare easily.
|