U.S. secretly tracks world's money web

Looking for evidence of terrorist activity, Treasury Department uses subpoenas to spy on suspicious wire transfers between banks - By Josh Meyer, Greg Miller
Los Angeles Times
Jun. 23, 2006

Washington -- The U.S. government, without the knowledge of many banks and their customers, has engaged for years in a secret effort to track terrorist financing by accessing a vast database of confidential information on transfers of money between banks worldwide.

The program, run by the Treasury Department, is considered a potent weapon in the war on terrorism because of its ability to clandestinely monitor financial transactions and map terrorist webs.

Current and former officials at multiple U.S. agencies acknowledged the program's existence but spoke on condition of anonymity, citing its sensitive nature. "We're very, very protective of it," said a senior U.S. official. "It is extremely valuable."

After the Los Angeles Times and other media outlets reported the existence of the program Thursday night, the Treasury Department issued a statement describing the broad subpoenas used to collect the financial records as "a legal and proper use of our authorities."

The program is part of an arsenal of aggressive measures the government has adopted since the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks that yield new intelligence, but also circumvent traditional safeguards against abuse and raise concerns about intrusions on privacy.

The program extracts information about bank transfers from the world's largest financial communication network, which is run by a consortium of financial institutions called the Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication, or SWIFT.

The SWIFT network routes about $6 trillion daily between banks, brokerages, stock exchanges and other institutions, and carries up to 12.7 million messages a day containing instructions on many of the international transfers of money between banks. The messages typically include the names and account numbers of bank customers -- from U.S. citizens to major corporations -- who are sending or receiving funds.

The program gives U.S. intelligence analysts extraordinary access into what is essentially the central nervous system of international banking.

The Treasury Department uses a little-known power -- administrative subpoenas -- to routinely seek data from the SWIFT network, which has operations in the United States, including a main computer hub in Manassas, Va. The subpoenas are secret and not reviewed by judges or grand juries, as are most criminal subpoenas.

SWIFT acknowledged Thursday that it has provided data under subpoena since shortly after Sept. 11, a striking leap in cooperation from international bankers who long resisted such law enforcement intrusions into the confidentiality of their communications. But SWIFT said in a statement that it has worked with U.S. officials to restrict the use of the data to terrorism investigations.

The program is part of the Bush administration's dramatic expansion of intelligence-gathering capabilities, which includes warrantless eavesdropping on the international phone calls of some U.S. citizens. Critics complain that these efforts are not subject to independent governmental reviews designed to prevent abuse and charge that they collide with privacy and consumer protection laws in the United States.

Steven Aftergood, director of the Project on Government Secrecy at the Federation of American Scientists, said the SWIFT program raises similar issues. "It boils down to a question of oversight, both internal and external. And in the current circumstances, it is hard to have confidence in the efficacy of their oversight," he said. "Their policy is, 'Trust us,' and that may not be good enough anymore."

A former senior Treasury official expressed concern that the SWIFT program allows access to vast quantities of sensitive data that could be abused without safeguards. The official, who said he did not have independent knowledge of the program, questioned what becomes of the data, some of it presumably on innocent banking customers.

"How do you separate the wheat from the chaff?" the former official said. "And what do you do with the chaff?"

The effort also runs counter to the expectations of privacy and security that are sacrosanct in the worldwide banking community. SWIFT promotes its services largely by touting the network's security, and most of its customers are likely unaware that the U.S. government is regularly using subpoenas to review the private financial information.

U.S. officials, some of whom expressed surprise the program had not previously been revealed, acknowledged it would be controversial in the financial community. "It is certainly not going to sit well in the world marketplace," said the former counterterrorism official. "It could very likely undermine the integrity of SWIFT."

In a statement Thursday night, the White House defended the propriety of the program.

"Since immediately following 9/11, the American government has taken every legal measure to prevent another attack on our country," said Dana Perino, deputy White House press secretary. "One of the most important tools in the fight against terror is our ability to choke off funds for the terrorists."

Officials familiar with the program offer conflicting descriptions of whether it allows access only to financial data relating to individual terrorist suspects, or to a much broader range of data that would sweep up innocent people as well.

The senior U.S. official said U.S. authorities subpoena SWIFT data only when they have specific intelligence that connects an individual or company to suspected terrorist activity. "This program is legal, it is properly run, it's got oversight," he said. "It's exactly what you want your government to be doing."

But a former U.S. official, who is also familiar with the program, characterized it as more comprehensive than individual searches. "I think it's more than targeted. I don't know that it's the whole network, but it's very broad."

The program was initially a closely guarded secret, but over the years it has become known to a steadily wider circle of government officials, former officials, banking executives and outside experts.

Current and former U.S. officials say the effort has only been marginally successful against al Qaeda, which long ago began transferring money through other means, including the highly informal banking system common in Islamic countries.

The value of the program, they said, has been in tracking lower- and mid-level terrorist operatives and financiers who believe they have not been detected, and militant groups, such as Hezbollah and Hamas, that also operate political and social welfare organizations.

It's no secret that the Treasury Department tries to track terrorist financing, or that those efforts ramped up significantly after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks. But the SWIFT program goes far beyond what has been publicly disclosed about that effort in terms of the amount of financial data that U.S. intelligence agencies can access.

The program also represents a major tactical shift. U.S. investigators have long been able to subpoena records on specific accounts or transactions when they could show cause -- a painstaking process designed mainly for gathering evidence. But access to SWIFT enables them to follow suspicious financial trails around the globe, identifying new suspects without having to seek assistance from foreign banks.

SWIFT said that the Office of Foreign Assets Control in the Treasury Department sent the first subpoena shortly after Sept. 11, seeking "limited sets of data" to learn about how al Qaeda financed the attacks.

Unlike telephone lines and e-mail communications, the SWIFT network cannot be easily tapped. It uses secure log-ins and state-of-the-art encryption technology to prevent intercepted messages from being deciphered. "It is arguably the most secure network on the planet," said the former SWIFT executive who spoke on condition of anonymity. "This thing is locked down like Fort Knox."

SWIFT said that it was responding to compulsory subpoenas and negotiated with U.S. officials to narrow them and to establish protections for the privacy of its customers. SWIFT also said it has never given U.S. authorities direct access to its network.

"Our fundamental principle has been to preserve the confidentiality of users' data while complying with the lawful obligations in countries where we operate," SWIFT said in its statement.

No outside governmental oversight body, such as the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court or a grand jury, monitors the subpoenas served on SWIFT.

Current and former U.S. officials said subpoenas must be approved by a senior Treasury administrator and, the senior U.S. official said, are limited to a "targeted search on a known name where there is an intelligence nexus."

But the official said it's used frequently.

"Treasury has gone painstakingly, in my view, to ensure the legality," said a former U.S. counterterrorism official. "They have been pretty conservative there."

SWIFT said it "has insisted on protecting the data, narrowing the scope, and limiting access and use to terrorism investigations," and said that "independent audit controls provide additional assurance that these protections are fully complied with."

A SWIFT representative said Booz Allen Hamilton is the auditor, but provided no further details on how the oversight process works.

Although the searches focus on suspected terrorist activity overseas, U.S. officials acknowledged that they do delve into the financial activities of Americans, noting that privacy laws don't protect individuals believed to be acting as a foreign terrorist agent.

A senior U.S. official and others familiar with the program said they could not discuss how many searches have been conducted or how successful they have been. SWIFT also declined to provide information on subpoenas, but said, "Our understanding is that it has been very valuable."

Current and former U.S. officials said a second program, run by the FBI, is similar in that it seeks to access the financial records of a vast number of individuals, including Americans, who do not know that the information is being accessed.

Officials said the administration has briefed congressional intelligence committees on the SWIFT program, in contrast to the way the information on the National Security Agency wiretapping was withheld. One senior congressional aide said the committees have "a good handle on what the executive branch is doing to track terrorist financing" and are generally supportive of those efforts.

But the operation seems to have been kept secret from key segments of the banking industry, including senior banking executives in the United States and overseas.

SWIFT noted that its published policies clearly indicate that it cooperates with law enforcement authorities and that the subpoenas were "discussed carefully within the board," made up of members from 25 major banks. SWIFT said it has also kept informed an oversight committee drawn from the central banks of the major industrial countries.

Chronicle news services contributed to this report.













All original InformationLiberation articles CC 4.0



About - Privacy Policy