Afghan War Is Not Over, Says Judge, So Indefinite Detention Can ContinueThough President Obama has publicaly championed end of combat operations in Afghanistan, that doesn't mean prisoners of war can be releasedby Jon Queally Common Dreams Aug. 02, 2015 |
Israel's Chickens Come Home to Roost
Jon Stewart and Steven Levitksky: The Constitution is 'The Problem'
Ben Shapiro: It's an 'Anti-Semitic Conspiracy Theory' to Say Congress Banning TikTok for Israel
U.S. House Rams Through Bill to Ban TikTok
Gaza on Brink of Mass Starvation and Death, U.N.-Backed Monitor Reports
A federal judge on Thursday rejected the petition of a Guantanamo detainee who had requested to be freed after spending nearly a decade and a half in the U.S. offshore prison without trial. As the Associated Press reports: Muktar Yahya Najee al-Warafi has said his detention was illegal in light of President Barack Obama's statements that active hostilities in Afghanistan had ended.For many, however, the very existence of the offshore prison remains an absurdy and affront to the U.S. Constitution, international theories of jurisprudence, and recognized humamn rights standards. As Noah Feldman, a columnist for Bloomberg wrote on Thursday, "more than 50 [prisoners] remain in legal limbo, treated as permanent prisoners of war in a conflict that has no way to end. Their detention calls into question the basic ideas of due process, no matter what legal justification the federal government gives for it." In the long run, continues Feldman, the legal system that has enabled the U.S. government to hold these men not only defies logic, but actually undermines the legitimacy of the entire justice system. He concludes: The U.S. government says it's within its rights to keep them as prisoners of war in the conflict with al-Qaida. But the POW rules assume a conflict between international parties that might conceivably be ended by a peace treaty. There will be no such end to the legal conflict between al-Qaida and the U.S. That means the detainees can be held forever. |