The news you're not supposed to know...

Austrian Economics: Understand Economics, Understand the World
The Century of the Self: The Untold History of Controlling the Masses Through the Manipulation of Unconscious Desires
The Disappearing Male: From Virility to Sterility

The Obama Deception: The Mask Comes Off
Operation Gladio: The Hidden History of U.S. Sponsored False Flag Terrorism in EuropeThe New American Century: The Untold History of The Project for the New American Century
Article posted Mar 22 2013, 3:52 PM Category: Big Brother/Orwellian Source: Print

AP v. Meltwater: Disappointing Ruling for News Search

BY CORYNNE MCSHERRY AND KURT OPSAHL, Electronic Frontier Foundation

A federal district judge in New York City issued a troubling ruling today holding that an electronic news clipping service infringed copyright when it republished excerpts of news stories in search results for its clients seeking news coverage based on particular keywords.

The case is Associated Press v. Meltwater. Meltwater is a private subscription service that scans news sites for stories relevant to its clients and then delivers the search results in the form of short excerpts from, and links to, the original articles. News service Associated Press claimed the search results infringed its copyrights in the news articles included within them. Meltwater argued that its service was a noninfringing fair use. EFF filed an amicus brief supporting Meltwater.  

The court's fair use analysis is worrisome in at least three respects. First, the court concluded that Meltwater's purpose was not transformative because it neither added commentary or insight to the excerpts it sent to customers nor served the same information-finding goal as a search engine like Google.  Why not? In a nutshell, apparently because it was not public and not very successful at getting its customers to click through to the original articles.  Given that the court devoted several pages of text explaining how Meltwater was like a search engine (i.e., it scans the web for news and creates an index that allows customers to search for relevant information) it is difficult for us to see why the fairness of its purpose should turn on its success at getting customers to actually click through the links it provided. The court took great care to distinguish what it saw as "legitimate" search engines -- but we can expect more litigation over what counts as "legitimate."

Second, the court implicitly adopted AP's dangerous "heart of the work" theory.  AP contended that sharing excerpts of a news article must weigh against fair use if those excerpts contain the lede.  The court stressed that the lede is "consistently important" and takes "significant journalistic skill to craft." But that is beside the point -- there is no extra protection because something is extra difficult. More important to the fair use analysis is the fact that (1) is primarily factual; and (2) contains precisely the information the user wishes to make known to others. As we explained in our amicus brief, this case illustrates why the heart of the work doctrine does not mesh well with highly factual, published, news articles. When it comes to news articles, an excerpt that is shared will very often be the most "important" aspect of the work -- but that importance will derive from the uncopyrightable factual content, not the expression. It is not the "heart of the work," but a piece of the factual skeleton upon which the expression hangs.

Third, the court discounted the value of robots.txt files to provide permission.  Robots.txt files give sites a tool to disallow (or allow) certain crawlers, and other courts have sensibly looked to robots.txt to find whether there was permission to include a site in search results. The default is permission, which a file can remove. This voluntary system has been vital to the development of tool to help users find material online. While the court does not directly disagree with the leading robots.txt cases, it finds they do not apply here.

There's a lot more in this 91-page ruling, much of it troubling. Meltwater has said "We're considering all of our options, but we look forward to having this decision reviewed by the Court of Appeals."



Latest Big Brother/Orwellian
- Drudge on AJ: Copyright Laws Will Destroy the Internet
- Homeland Security Detains Stockton Mayor, Forces Him to Hand Over His Passwords
- GCHQ's Karma Police: Tracking and Profiling Every Web User, Every Web Site
- Senate Intelligence Committee Ends Efforts To Turn Social Media Companies Into Government Spies
- Mandatory Breathalyzers Could Soon Be in Every Car If Feds Have Their Way
- Glenn Greenwald Debates Former NSA Director Keith B. Alexander At HP Conference
- NY Pushing for Black Boxes in Your Car That Records Everything About Your Driving
- DHS Targets Library for Supporting Anonymous Internet Browsing

No Comments Posted Add Comment

Add Comment


Verification *
Please Enter the Verification Code Seen Below

Please see our About Page, our Disclaimer, and our Comments Policy.

This site contains copyrighted material the use of which in some cases has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material is made available for the purposes of news reporting, education, research, comment, and criticism, which constitutes a 'fair use' of such copyrighted material in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. It is our policy to respond to notices of alleged infringement that comply with the DMCA and other applicable intellectual property laws. It is our policy to remove material from public view that we believe in good faith to be copyrighted material that has been illegally copied and distributed by any of our members or users.

About Us - Disclaimer - Privacy Policy

Advanced Search


Remember Me
Forgot Password?

VIDEO: Dashcam Refutes Cop's Story of "Fearing For His Life," Shows Him Taser Man For Parking Ticket - 10/06VIDEO: Woman Reports Cop's Rude Behavior, Cop Retaliates By Pulling Her Over & Beating Her - 10/05Drudge on AJ: Copyright Laws Will Destroy the Internet - 10/06Woman Called 911 to Report Stolen Wallet, Crazed Cop Showed Up and Beat Her Unconscious - 10/06'Neutralizing' John Lennon: One Man Against The 'Monster' - 10/06Cops Lied to Get Innocent Disabled Man Imprisoned for Elderly Woman's Rape & Murder, Hid Contradictory Evidence - 10/05VIDEO: Cop Smashes Suspect's Face With Shotgun, Gets Charged With Felony - 10/05Video: 'I Get Falsely Arrested Then My House Gets Robbed Live On Twitch.Tv Livestream' - 10/05

Man Follows Speeding Cop, Finds Out He Was Speeding To Buy PeanutsMission Creeps: Homeland Security Agents Confiscate Women's Panties For 'Copyright Infringement'Cop Shoots Couple's Dog, Threatens Jail For Trying To Save Dog's LifeSWAT Team Shoots Teen Girl & Her Dog During Pot Raid On Wrong HomeDurham, NC Cop Testifies Faking 911 Calls To Enter Homes Is "Official Policy"Indiana Sheriff Says US A "War Zone" To Justify New MRAP Military VehicleTampa Cops Surveil Pot Dealer, Catch Him Selling Pot, Raid His Home & Kill Him"You Just Shot An Unarmed Man!": Witness Says Police Shot His Friend With His Hands Up