FBI Claims Wikipedia Can't Display Its Logoby Mike MasnickTechdirt Aug. 03, 2010 |
Trump Bombs Three Iranian Nuclear Sites, Calls for 'Peace' After Expanding War
Opponents of Israel Are All Russian and Iranian Bots, ADL-Funded Group 'NCRI' Says
Report: U.S. Gave Iran Advance Notice of 'One-Off' Strike on Nuclear Sites
Pentagon Official Purged From Joint Chiefs of Staff for Posts Calling Israel 'Our Worst Ally'
Ted Cruz Reveals U.S. Helping Israel Carry Out Military Strikes on Iran
![]() ![]() Wikipedia's General Counsel, Mike Godwin (yes, of Godwin's law fame) responded to the FBI with a delightfully snarky reply (pdf) noting that the FBI's reading of the law concerning displaying an FBI badge is clearly written to prevent people from falsely presenting themselves as being with the FBI or directly profiting from the use of the seal: Godwin notes that the version of the law that the FBI conveniently sent him just happened to omit some parts of the law, which basically show that the law is entirely focused on such attempts to use the logo to deceive. Among the key passages: Entertainingly, in support for your argument, you included a version of 701 in which you removed the very phrases that subject the statute to ejusdem generis analysis. While we appreciate your desire to revise the statute to reflect your expansive vision of it, the fact is that we must work with the actual language of the statute, not the aspirational version of Section 701 that you forwarded to us.Godwin also points out that the Encyclopaedia Britannica appears to have an image of the logo as well. As for our own usage here, I'll first note that the NY Times is also displaying the logo with its story, and it would seem that all three of us are similarly not running afoul of this law, in that none of us are using the logo with any attempt to deceive at all, but to display factual information for the sake of informing. |