informationliberation
The news you're not supposed to know...




An Introduction to Austrian Economics: Understand Economics, Understand Everything
The Century of the Self: The Untold History of Controlling the Masses Through the Manipulation of Unconscious Desires
The Disappearing Male: From Virility to Sterility

The Obama Deception: The Mask Comes Off
Operation Gladio: The Hidden History of U.S. Sponsored False Flag Terrorism in EuropeThe New American Century: The Untold History of The Project for the New American Century
(more)
Article posted Mar 28 2013, 10:48 PM Category: Big Brother/Orwellian Source: EFF.org Print

Congress' New CFAA Draft Could Have Put Aaron Swartz in Jail For Decades Longer Than the Original Charges

BY TREVOR TIMM, Electronic Frontier Foundation

Law professor and historian Tim Wu has called the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA) the "worst law in technology." The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has described the government's interpretation of it "expansive," "broad," and "sweeping." And Orin Kerr, former federal prosecutor and law professor, has detailed how the government could use it to put "any Internet user they want [in jail]."

So it's pretty surprising to see that now, instead of reining in the CFAA's dangerous reach, the House Judiciary Committee is floating a proposal to dramatically expand it and is reportedly planning to rush it to the floor of Congress during its April "cyber" week.

The CFAA, of course, is also the computer trespass law that prosecutors misused to hound the late activist and Internet pioneer Aaron Swartz. Aaron's tragic death resulted in outrage across the political spectrum and led to calls for real reform that would bring the law back to its reasonable purpose of criminalizing malicious computer intrusions, rather than handing out draconian penalties for minor infractions and turning terms of service violations into criminal acts.

So why is the House Judiciary Committee floating a proposal that goes so clearly against the public opinion? Their reasoning is almost hard to fathom.

Techdirt's Mike Masnick posted a new draft and analysis of the CFAA expansion bill on Monday. The changes are nothing short of outrageous and should brand supporters in Congress as out of touch and downright hostile to the Internet. Users concerned about Internet rights should contact their representatives immediately.

Perhaps the most disturbing aspect: instead of reducing the penalties for crimes that don't cause much economic damage, it dramatically increases them. For example, Aaron faced four charges under section (a)(4) of the CFAA, which had a maximum sentence of five years each. EFF, Orin Kerr and many others have proposed removing (a)(4) entirely since it creates double penalties for the same behavior criminalized elsewhere in the law.  What does the new draft do? It increases the maximum under (a)(4) to twenty years for each charge. As Internet law scholar James Grimmelmann remarked Monday, the thought of Aaron facing more time is "simply obscene."

The new draft also now turns CFAA violations into a "racketeering" offense, adding yet another layer of charges the DOJ can add to the charge sheet of a hacker it doesn't like. It also adds a broad conspiracy charge that carries the same penalty for actually committing an offense. Essentially, talking about committing computer crimes without actually doing so can land you in prison.

Most troublingly for innovation and for user empowerment, the bill "clarifies" its definition of "exceeding authorized access" to include  accessing information for an "impermissible purpose"--even if you have permission to access the information in the first place. That codifies the misguided idea that any terms of service violation is indeed a crime, effectively undoing good rulings in the 9th and 4th Circuits.

The CFAA already reaches computer intrusions, serious denial of service attacks, password misuse and attacks on national security computers.  Those provisions are important. The Department of Justice has more than enough tools it needs to go after real criminals using this law and a host of others--including criminal copyright, trade secrets, identity theft and other laws. It should use those tools rather than coming back to Congress for more, especially now that it's just been caught misusing the law so egregiously in Aaron's case. 

Quite simply, this bill is a nightmare for Internet users' rights. That the House Judiciary Committee would introduce it in the wake of Aaron's death demonstrates just how out of step they are.

Law professor Orin Kerr agrees, concluding the proposed bill's language is a "a step backward, not a step forward" and says its meant "to give DOJ what it wants, not to amend the CFAA in a way that would narrow it."

One thing is clear: Congress is not going to fix the CFAA without an enormous, sustained effort from regular folks to implore them to fix it. In fact, this proposal shows that if we stand silent, they are likely to make it worse. Let's remind Congress about the last time they decided to go against the wishes of Internet users across the country--CFAA could be SOPA II.   

Call your member of Congress and tell them that representing you means that they will work to fix the CFAA, not make it worse. Tell them that the CFAA already carries incredibly harsh penalties for conduct that would be considered a minor crime, or no crime at all, in the physical world. Tell them that the law meant for real criminals, should not also engulf activists, security researchers, innovators, and entrepreneurs.

In the name of Aaron--and the next person to face an overreaching prosecutor harboring a grudge--implore them to fix the CFAA.





Latest Big Brother/Orwellian
- Los Angeles Law Enforcement Looking To Crowdsource Surveillance
- TSA Ejects Mute, Disabled Woman From Flight Because She Couldn't Speak
- NSA Exploited Heartbleed for Own Use
- An NSA 'Reform Bill' of the Intelligence Community, Written by the Intelligence Community, and for the Intelligence Community
- Britain to Jail Parents Who Don't Love Their Children Enough
- Clapper Confesses: NSA Searching Americans' Calls and Emails
- "You Can Keep Your Doctor. Oh, And We're Not Listening To Your Phone Calls."
- The Rebranding Of SOPA: Now Called 'Notice And Staydown'









No Comments Posted Add Comment


Add Comment
Name
Comment

* No HTML


Verification *
Please Enter the Verification Code Seen Below
 


PLEASE NOTE
Please see our About Page, our Disclaimer, and our Comments Policy.


FAIR USE NOTICE
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which in some cases has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material is made available for the purposes of news reporting, education, research, comment, and criticism, which constitutes a 'fair use' of such copyrighted material in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. It is our policy to respond to notices of alleged infringement that comply with the DMCA and other applicable intellectual property laws. It is our policy to remove material from public view that we believe in good faith to be copyrighted material that has been illegally copied and distributed by any of our members or users.

About Us - Disclaimer - Privacy Policy



Advanced Search
Username:

Password:

Remember Me
Forgot Password?
Register

Illinois Cops Caught Red-Handed Lying Under Oath In Marijuana Case - 04/16Cop Swerves His SUV Into Longboarders To Enforce $35 Bylaw Violation - 04/14Peoria, Illinois Mayor Orders Police Raid Over Parody Twitter Account - 04/18SC Man Facing Federal Charges Over $.89 Drink Refill - 04/17The Disturbing Messages in Police Recruiting Videos - 04/17Ranchers vs. Regulators: The Clark County Range War - 04/17Bundy, the Senecas and Fighting for Sovereignty - 04/17Deputy Tries To Shoot Dog, Shoots Himself Instead - 04/18

Rialto, CA Police Made to Wear Cameras, Use of Force Drops by Over Two-ThirdsCop Who Karate Chopped NY Judge In Throat Gets Off Scot-FreeFlorida Cop Smashes Compliant Woman's Face Into Car -- "Maybe Now You Can Understand Simple Instructions"VIDEO: Lapel Cam Reveals A Day In The Life Of A U.S. Police Officer (Tasing, Beating, Breaking & Entering, Stomping On Heads... and Laughing About It)Caught On Tape: Officer Sucker Punches Inmate In Face, Files Report Claiming 'Self Defense'Insult Person On Twitter, Go To JailSWAT Team Brings TV Crew To Film Raid Against Threatening Internet Critic -- Raids Innocent Grandma InsteadCop Karate Chops NY Judge In The Throat
(more)

 
Top