informationliberation
The news you're not supposed to know...




An Introduction to Austrian Economics: Understand Economics, Understand Everything
The Century of the Self: The Untold History of Controlling the Masses Through the Manipulation of Unconscious Desires
The Disappearing Male: From Virility to Sterility

The Obama Deception: The Mask Comes Off
Operation Gladio: The Hidden History of U.S. Sponsored False Flag Terrorism in EuropeThe New American Century: The Untold History of The Project for the New American Century
(more)
Article posted Aug 01 2012, 10:05 PM Category: Economy Source: Jeffrey Tucker Print

Government Is Shrinking?

by Jeffrey Tucker

In today's political climate, the more implausible the claim, the more likely it is to stick. One that seems to be sticking now is that government today is small by historical standards and constantly shrinking.

Run that one by the man on the street looted by the tax man, harassed by police, hounded by regulators and he will scoff. Now comes the highbrow journalist with a nuanced view to correct him, citing all kinds of complex data.

The highbrow in this case is Catherine Rampell, writing in The New York Times. Her claim seems apodictically certain. "Government has been shrinking steadily for two years," she says, "and compared to the size of the overall economy, government is actually slightly smaller today than it has been on average in the postwar era."

Huh? Well, she provides data of "the percentage change in total government spending and investment" as compared with the change in the GDP. She shows GDP rises and government falls. Wow, amazing.

Not so fast. You can always know that when people claim that government is small, it will always appear small by comparison to the GDP, which is to say that anything looks small by comparison to anything (in the words of economist Roger Garrison).

Moreover, it is a peculiar presumption that government should always grow in proportion to the wealth of society (presuming that GDP does measure that). Why? If government is providing essential and minimal functions only, it should get smaller in proportion to economic growth. Should the thief keep coming back for more when his victim grows wealthier?

Also, shrinking by comparison to everything else doesn't mean that it literally gets smaller. It should only constitute a smaller portion of the total.

But that's only the beginning of Rampell's statistical antics. If you compare federal government spending as a percentage of GDP, it comes in at 24.3%, which is the highest in postwar history. In fact, it is the same as 1942, the year American troops landed in Europe.

So what is she talking about? Is she just making stuff up? Not exactly. She carefully says that she is looking at "the percentage change in total government spending and investment." More precisely, she is examining something called "government consumption expenditures and total investment," one of the ways that you can slice and dice national income accounting. This is the figure among many options that best makes her case. Piles of data had to be thrown in the trash can to generate the result she wanted.

As AmosWEB points out, this figure is the only one that completely excludes transfer payments, which are defined (arbitrarily) as not investment and not consumption, and includes all those things that (arbitrarily) fall into a specific category. It's a bit like saying that a giraffe is a horse if you exclude the neck.

Rampell even took the manipulation one step further to look at quarterly change in the data, and not the actual figure. Therefore, if government spends a trillion on a stimulus now and that stimulus runs out next year, it would seem to show a crash in spending. Surprise, that's exactly what happened!

Despite her rhetoric, then, we can see that she had to engage in three levels of distortion to come up with the claim that government is shrinking.

Let's say that we look at what most normal people would consider government spending, by which I mean the dollar figures on how much government actually spends. And let's add a column on debt so we can see the total unfulfilled commitments in the year in question too. There is nothing fancy pants here, just the raw truth, year by year.

YearFed government spendingFed government debt
2001$1.979 trillion$5.812 trillion
2002$2.112 trillion$6.192 trillion
2003$2.261 trillion$6.728 trillion
2004$2.393 trillion$7.345 trillion
2005$2.573 trillion$7.929 trillion
2006$2.728 trillion$8.494 trillion
2007$2.900 trillion$8.989 trillion
2008$3.116 trillion$9.914 trillion
2009$3.456 trillion$11.723 trillion
2010$3.703 trillion$13.390 trillion
2011$3.757 trillion$14.656 trillion

Now, I ask you: Does this look like steady shrinking to you?

In other words, the man of the street is exactly right. Think about these numbers when you hear pundits and politicians over the next months tell you how dramatically government is shrinking.

Of course, spending alone doesn't measure government size. If your front door is being broken down by feds, if you are jailed for violating regulations, if you are prevented from starting a business or if you can't hire new workers because of the high costs, government is effectively totalitarian from your point of view. In the last 10 years, this is largest change we've seen, from big government to police state. In the end, this is a change that no data set can quite capture.
_
Jeffrey Tucker is the publisher and executive editor of Laissez-Faire Books, the Primus inter pares of the Laissez Faire Club, and the author of Bourbon for Breakfast: Living Outside the Statist Quo and It's a Jetsons World: Private Miracles and Public Crimes, among thousands of articles. tucker@lfb.org | Facebook | Twitter





Latest Economy
- "They Just Want The Money!" - The IRS Can Now Seize Accounts On Suspicion Alone
- Hillary: 'Don't Let Anybody Tell You' That 'Businesses Create Jobs'
- Does Ebola Justify the State?
- Low Inflation? The Price Of Ground Beef Has Risen 17 Percent Over The Past Year
- EFF, Internet Archive, and reddit Oppose New York's BitLicense Proposal
- Who's Afraid of the Workers' Revolution?
- Sports Stadiums: Temples to Crony Capitalism
- Obamacare Architect Says Society Would Be Better Off If People Only Lived To Age 75









No Comments Posted Add Comment


Add Comment
Name
Comment

* No HTML


Verification *
Please Enter the Verification Code Seen Below
 


PLEASE NOTE
Please see our About Page, our Disclaimer, and our Comments Policy.


FAIR USE NOTICE
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which in some cases has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material is made available for the purposes of news reporting, education, research, comment, and criticism, which constitutes a 'fair use' of such copyrighted material in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. It is our policy to respond to notices of alleged infringement that comply with the DMCA and other applicable intellectual property laws. It is our policy to remove material from public view that we believe in good faith to be copyrighted material that has been illegally copied and distributed by any of our members or users.

About Us - Disclaimer - Privacy Policy



Advanced Search
Username:

Password:

Remember Me
Forgot Password?
Register

Florida Judge Halts Trial & Demands Charges Against Orlando Cop For Perjury - 10/31Bust You For It Now, Tax You For It Tomorrow: The Insanity of Marijuana Prohibition - 10/31How Cops Talk About Mundanes When They Think Nobody Else is Listening - 10/31Wisconsin Town Sends In The BearCat Tank To Collect Civil Fine From Seventy-Year-Old - 10/31LAPD Officer Accused Of Punting Man's Face Like He Was 'Kicking A Field Goal' - 10/30If You Vote or Don't Vote Complain - 10/31Mission Creeps: Homeland Security Agents Confiscate Women's Panties For 'Copyright Infringement' - 10/23FBI Agents Cut Internet Access, Pose As Repairmen To Perform Warrantless Search - 10/30

Rialto, CA Police Made to Wear Cameras, Use of Force Drops by Over Two-ThirdsCop Who Karate Chopped NY Judge In Throat Gets Off Scot-FreeFlorida Cop Smashes Compliant Woman's Face Into Car -- "Maybe Now You Can Understand Simple Instructions"VIDEO: Lapel Cam Reveals A Day In The Life Of A U.S. Police Officer (Tasing, Beating, Breaking & Entering, Stomping On Heads... and Laughing About It)Caught On Tape: Officer Sucker Punches Inmate In Face, Files Report Claiming 'Self Defense'Insult Person On Twitter, Go To JailSWAT Team Brings TV Crew To Film Raid Against Threatening Internet Critic -- Raids Innocent Grandma InsteadCop Karate Chops NY Judge In The Throat
(more)

 
Top