The news you're not supposed to know...

Austrian Economics: Understand Economics, Understand the World
The Century of the Self: The Untold History of Controlling the Masses Through the Manipulation of Unconscious Desires
The Disappearing Male: From Virility to Sterility

The Obama Deception: The Mask Comes Off
Operation Gladio: The Hidden History of U.S. Sponsored False Flag Terrorism in EuropeThe New American Century: The Untold History of The Project for the New American Century
Article posted Mar 07 2012, 4:25 PM Category: Commentary Source: Techdirt Print

Isn't It Time Artists Lost Their 18th-Century Sense Of Entitlement?

by Glyn Moody

One of the common assumptions in the copyright debate is that artists are special, and that they have a right to make money from their works repeatedly, in ways not granted to "ordinary" workers like plumbers or train drivers, thanks to copyright's reach through time and space. Of course, when modern copyright was devised in the early 18th century, artists were special in the sense they were scarce; offering them special monopoly privileges "for the encouragement of learning" as the 1710 Statute of Anne puts it, therefore made sense.

But the Internet has changed everything; it has allowed hundreds of millions of people -- soon billions -- to become active creators rather than passive consumers. That, in its turn, challenges the assumption that "professional" artists are special, and deserve special treatment. One prolific creator who seems to have accepted this is Seth Godin, who featured in Techdirt at the end of last year.

In an interview for Digital Book World, he is asked the classic question about how artists can make money if they share their work freely:
Rivera: Many authors hear your message about being willing to give away their books for free, or to focus on spreading their message but their question is: ďIíve got rent to pay so how do I turn that into cash money?Ē

Who said you have a right to cash money from writing? I gave hundreds of speeches before I got paid to write one. Iíve written more than 4000 blog posts for free.

Poets donít get paid (often), but thereís no poetry shortage. The future is going to be filled with amateurs, and the truly talented and persistent will make a great living. But the days of journeyman writers who make a good living by the word -- over.
As he notes, although he is a hugely-successful author and speaker today, and hence presumably well paid for both, he started out by giving away stuff -- lots of it. It was only after he had established his value in the market through that free content that he was able to to start asking to be paid for future work. In other words, just because he was a great writer and lecturer didn't mean he had an entitlement to be paid from the start; he had to prove he was worth paying before people did so. And even then, they paid not for what he had done, but what he would do -- just as you pay a plumber or train driver.

Some might dismiss Godin as an outlier, or a provocateur saying outrageous things in order to whip up a little publicity for himself and his projects (and he probably is, to a certain extent.) But as Matthew Ingram pointed out in a piece analyzing the same Godin interview, Godin is not alone. Here's Francis Ford Coppola expressing much the same views a year ago:
This idea of Metallica or some rock ní roll singer being rich, thatís not necessarily going to happen anymore. Because, as we enter into a new age, maybe art will be free. Maybe the students are right. They should be able to download music and movies. Iím going to be shot for saying this. But who said art has to cost money? And therefore, who says artists have to make money?
That's not to say artists shouldn't make money from their work in some way, just that the long-held assumption that artists must be paid directly for everything they do, again and again, and even after they are dead, because they are "special", simply isn't true any more -- assuming it ever was.

Follow me @glynmoody on Twitter or, and on Google+

Latest Commentary
- State Sterilization: Alive and Well in America
- Government Discrimination vs. Private Discrimination
- Mandatory Voting: A Bad Idea
- The Right to Discriminate Against Ellen Pao
- How The US Government and US Military Became Murder, Inc.
- Extradition Hypocrisy
- The Only Truly Compliant, Submissive Citizen in a Police State Is a Dead One
- Time to Replace the Boy Scouts?

Comments Add Comment Page 1 of 1

Posted: Mar 08 2012, 8:46 AM

8067 'Artists' seem to think they should get paid for every view of their film or
every playback of their song ..

In the case of Metallica, we have a bunch of guys who publicly have admitted to snorting millions of dollars worth of cocaine running around and calling their fans 'thieves' .. For quoting their 'lyrics' on fan-sites !
They even complained that all the 'thieving' prevented them from buying a private Island !!
Imagine if Lars Ulrich had been some poor coloured dude with 3 joints in his pocket ! He would STILL be in prison .

Add Comment


Verification *
Please Enter the Verification Code Seen Below

Please see our About Page, our Disclaimer, and our Comments Policy.

This site contains copyrighted material the use of which in some cases has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material is made available for the purposes of news reporting, education, research, comment, and criticism, which constitutes a 'fair use' of such copyrighted material in accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. It is our policy to respond to notices of alleged infringement that comply with the DMCA and other applicable intellectual property laws. It is our policy to remove material from public view that we believe in good faith to be copyrighted material that has been illegally copied and distributed by any of our members or users.

About Us - Disclaimer - Privacy Policy

Advanced Search


Remember Me
Forgot Password?

Bureaucrats Panic As Traffic Ticket Revenue Plummets Across U.S. - 03/30New England Cop Harasses Guy Walking Home, Gets Schooled - 03/31The Matthew Townsend Case: Official Retaliation, Not "Witness Intimidation" - 03/31Audio Released of Cop Shooting and Killing College Student for Speaking Disrespectfully - 03/31Plainclothes Cop Unleashed Racist Tirade On Uber Driver In New York - 03/31Here Comes Italy: The Next Country to Legalize Marijuana? - 03/31State Sterilization: Alive and Well in America - 03/31Student Records Teacher Threatening Kids, Gets Suspended - 03/30

Man Follows Speeding Cop, Finds Out He Was Speeding To Buy PeanutsMission Creeps: Homeland Security Agents Confiscate Women's Panties For 'Copyright Infringement'Cop Shoots Couple's Dog, Threatens Jail For Trying To Save Dog's LifeSWAT Team Shoots Teen Girl & Her Dog During Pot Raid On Wrong HomeDurham, NC Cop Testifies Faking 911 Calls To Enter Homes Is "Official Policy"Indiana Sheriff Says US A "War Zone" To Justify New MRAP Military VehicleTampa Cops Surveil Pot Dealer, Catch Him Selling Pot, Raid His Home & Kill Him"You Just Shot An Unarmed Man!": Witness Says Police Shot His Friend With His Hands Up